• Carolyn Thomas

Right rose, right place

Updated: Jul 4


My only experience with choosing and planting a new rose (as opposed to moving into a home that already had roses in the garden) was back in the late 90s when I read an article about an amazingly fast-growing rose called Kiftsgate. The article said:


"Kiftsgate' is an extremely vigorous rambling rose, bearing masses of small, single, cream-white flowers with a strong musk fragrance, followed by red oval-shaped rose hips. It's ideal for growing through large trees or to cover large unsightly buildings or walls."


Extremely vigorous? Fragrant blooms? I had to have it! This was just what I needed for a bare two-storey vinyl siding wall overlooking my Vic West townhouse patio. I couldn't get that Kiftsgate rose out of my mind, picturing how lovely it would look scrambling up all that unsightly siding. Kiftsgate is named after its original home on one of those stately English estates - where the largest Kiftsgate rose in England is hundreds of years old and still thriving in a gorgeous garden cared for by three generations of female gardeners.


I couldn't find any Kiftsgates at local garden shops, but I did find it in a mail order rose catalogue from the north end of Vancouver Island (I live down at the south end, several hours drive away). I ordered my Kiftsgate, and about a month later a delivery truck arrived from up-island. The rose looked like a short bare stick, about the thickness of my thumb, sticking out of a one-gallon black plastic pot of dirt. Not too promising, but I plunked the stick hopefully into the hole I'd dug for it, and waited for summer to arrive.


My Kiftsgate rambling rose in full glorious June bloom!

The Kiftsgate took off nicely that first year, reaching the patio roof in just one season. The second year it reached the top of the second storey, and covered the upstairs balcony railing in the most charming fashion. By the third year, it had reached way up past the roof and all of our neighbours from the next block over could see it. I sold that townhouse in 2007 and my Kiftsgate was still going strong - by then a famous summer show stopper around our neighbourhood.


You're probably wanting your own Kiftsgate rambling rose right about now. But this is the important point at which you must fight that urge to buy this or any other rose - temporarily. I've learned so far that choosing the right rose for the right place is critical to our success as novice growers. I wrote more on that and how I decided on my Popcorn Drift rose for the balcony, or how my favourite son Ben became my rose-growing buddy.


UPDATE: Ben finally plants (most of) his pre-ordered bare root roses in his back garden! Find out how this miracle happened!


See also: Planting the First Roses Out on My Balcony


Before you plant your new rose, answer these questions:


1. Am I expecting the PERFECT ROSE?

I've also learned that there are very very good roses, but there is no perfect rose. And besides, you can't always get what you want, as the Rolling Stones reminded us. In future posts, we'll look at the importance of matching what you value most in a rose with what a given rose is actually able to give you. I thought my Kiftsgate was near-perfect, for example - until its relatively short and intense blooming period ended and I then spent every day sweeping up a non-stop storm of dying brown petals for the next two months.


2. Does the spot I've picked for my rose get SUN most of the day?

If not, you and your rose may not live happily ever after. Most experienced rose gardeners claim that 5-8 hours of full sun is the ideal needed for a truly happy rosebush. You may be able to get a rose to limp along in semi-shaded areas (as long as the shade is not caused by trees - which can also affect the soil's water content) but chances are you won't be thrilled - which is what I've decided roses are all about. Lack of sunshine can also increase the likelihood of attracting insects or diseases like Black Spot. JUNE UPDATE: I'm starting to worry, just a wee tiny bit, that our unseasonably drizzly and cool spring so far has affected the way my four Drift roses are growing alongside the balcony railing: for weeks, there just hasn't been those long lovely periods of sunshine to encourage sturdy stems. Instead, the stems seem downright thin and frail. * How will they ever be able to support the weight of the blooms once all the new fresh buds open up? Will I have droopy stems too weak to stand up? MORE JUNE UPDATES: it just got worse out there. YES, the dreaded Black Spot!


3. What do I want, what I really really want?

Do I want a smallish ground cover rosebush that won't get too tall, or a medium-sized shrub rose, or a standard "tree" rose for a formal garden or patio, or a fragrant rose for planting near an entrance gate, or a rose that will look lovely in a hanging basket, or a care-free rose that's resistant to nasty rose diseases, or a repeat bloomer that just keeps blooming until frost, or a big giant rambling rose like Kiftsgate, or a climbing rose (which, surprisingly, is not the same as a rambler)?


Here's a brief response to that last question, which turns out to be confusing for many would-be rose growers: CLIMBERS generally have larger blooms on not-too-vigorous, stiff growth and most of them repeat flower (meaning a big show in June/July - peak rose blooming months! - usually followed by one or more lesser repeat blooms until frost). RAMBLERS tend to be much more vigorous. They will produce great quantities of small flowers, but most do NOT repeat flower. It's almost as if they burn themselves out putting on their spectacular June/July show. This is important because it means that the big tall rose that dominates your garden will basically be covered with unsightly dying blooms from July until the first frost. And that was the problem with my own otherwise perfect fast-growing Kiftsgate.


The bottom line: don't pick out your new rose based on just the glossy full-colour photo on the plant tag (because all plant tags are designed to look irresistibly gorgeous). First, identify what you really really want out of your new rose, and then search for plants that will specifically meet your criteria.


In our next post, we'll look at specific characteristics of other types of roses that may be important to you - especially important when you find out too late that the rosebush you've just planted lacks that quality. Try not to go rose-shopping until you come back and read that one.


JULY UPDATE: Yipppeeeee! Lots of excitement out on the balcony this week (FINALLY!) Read more for the wonderful details - plus a few not-so-wonderful problems encountered along the way.


Until then, remember to s-l-o-w down and take time to smell the roses. . .


* P.S. Remember me whining about those thin and frail-looking stems on my Red Drift? Here's a reminder not to panic at every issue - check out how strong that rose looks today. . .



117 views0 comments

Recent Posts

See All